Skip Navigation
Pool front at Amara Cay Resort
Amara Cay Resort at Islamorada
The lovely nature of Amara Cay Resort
Hotel room at Amara Cay Resort
The beach of Amara Cay Resort
King sized Hotel room at Amara Cay Resort

Fresh and effortless, like the idyllic island setting of Islamorada, our guest rooms and suites inspire relaxation with chic coastal design and a calm neutral palette. Retreat to premium bedding and upscale amenities. Bathe yourself in the warm glow of the sunrise from your private ocean view balcony or oceanfront lanai. Experience the sophistication of island living at its finest with each stay at Amara Cay.

A Davidson Hospitality Group Hotel
  • Yoga
  • Pool Bar
  • Outdoor Adventure
  • Beach
  • Pet Friendly
  • Private Events & Meetings
  • Weddings
  • Kids Activities
  • Pools & Hot Tubs
  • Boating & Water Sports
  • Sightseeing
  • Resorts

True Flavors of The Keys

The resort's restaurants connect guests to the true flavors of the Keys from sunrise breakfast on a lanai, lunch with local ingredients at ReelCatch, dinner with pristine ocean views at Tiki Bar, to live music and cocktails at Coastal Cup & Lounge.

Beachfront Weddings

Amara Cay Resort provides a one-of-a-kind setting for the perfect Florida Keys wedding, offering several unique outdoor venues, coastal cuisine, and world-class service.

Stay & Explore All 3

When you stay at one of the resorts in the Islamorada Resort Collection--Amara Cay Resort, Postcard Inn Beach Resort or Pelican & La Siesta Resort & Marina-- you'll have access to explore the unique amenities, events, and restaurants of four resorts. Guests enjoy free shuttle service between each resort as well as nearby attractions.

Watersports in The Keys

To explore the island by sea, the resort offers paddleboards and kayaks. For guests looking for adventure, the resort can arrange boat excursions, snorkeling, diving, and fishing charters.

More Properties

king room
Olive Ann Hotel Exterior
front desk
king room 2

The Olive Ann Hotel

Grand Forks, North Dakota

Property details

Royal Park Hotel

Rochester, Michigan

Property details

Hotel Revival

Baltimore, Maryland

Property details
Grand Hotel Michigan

We approach our business with an owner’s mentality and financial cunning, yet we embody hospitality with deep reverence to our craft. Boasting some of the most talented and well-respected talent in hospitality, Davidson consistently delivers value to our team members and owners through highly specialized and innovative service.