Amara Cay Resort
Fresh and effortless, like the idyllic island setting of Islamorada, our guest rooms and suites inspire relaxation with chic coastal design and a calm neutral palette. Retreat to premium bedding and upscale amenities. Bathe yourself in the warm glow of the sunrise from your private ocean view balcony or oceanfront lanai. Experience the sophistication of island living at its finest with each stay at Amara Cay.
A Davidson Hospitality Group Hotel
Cabanas in Paradise
At Amara Cay, the resort’s new poolside cabanas offer luxurious relaxation with plush furnishings and private, shaded retreats amidst tropical surroundings. Guests enjoy a credit to spend at the resort's Tiki Bar, making it an ideal spot to sip cocktails and soak in stunning pool views, ensuring a memorable escape with added indulgence.
True Flavors of The Keys
Your stay at Amara Cay opens the door to its two sister resorts—La Siesta Resort & Villas and Three Waters Resort & Marina—where you can explore 12 distinct culinary destinations across the collection, all just a scenic boat ride away, included with your stay. At Amara Cay, start your day with a sunrise breakfast on a breezy lanai, then unwind with stunning ocean views at Tiki Bar and savor fresh, locally inspired cuisine at ReelCatch. Each experience offers a unique taste of island life and invites you to discover all three resorts.
Beachfront Weddings
Amara Cay Resort provides a one-of-a-kind setting for the perfect Florida Keys wedding, offering several unique outdoor venues, coastal cuisine, and world-class service.
Your Gateway to the Water
Discover the best of the Florida Keys from shore to sea with access to all three resorts. Paddleboards and kayaks offer a relaxed way to explore, while nearby Three Waters Resort & Marina features a full-service marina and a selection of experienced captains ready to guide your next adventure. From snorkeling and diving to unforgettable fishing charters in Islamorada, the Sportfishing Capital of the World, every experience is within reach, just a scenic boat ride away, included with your stay.
Experiences
Find your next adventure below! This hotel has curated these unique, local experiences for you to enjoy. Reserve your experience now, then complete your hotel reservation!
Spearfishing, Lobstering & Fishing
Experience Florida Keys Spearfishing
More
Tiki Party Boat - Private Charters
Experience The Best Sandbar Party and Sunset Cruise Boat in The Florida Keys
More
Jet Ski Rentals & Guided Tours
It's Hard Not To Have Fun When You’re Riding A Waverunner On The Atlantic!
More
Oceanfront Massage
Let Our Team Indulge You With the Finest Massage
More
Ocean Golf
Take A Swing And Feed Some Fish With Our Eco-Bio Friendly Golf Ball Driving Range
More
Beachside Yoga
Come Experience The Soft Island Breeze And Turquoise Blue Waters As You Move Through A Relaxing Yoga Session
More
Engagement Photo Session
Memorialize Your Love
More
Family/Couples Photo Session
Capture The Relaxed And Real Moment Full Of Sunshine
MoreMore Properties
We approach our business with an owner’s mentality and financial cunning, yet we embody hospitality with deep reverence to our craft. Boasting some of the most talented and well-respected talent in hospitality, Davidson consistently delivers value to our team members and owners through highly specialized and innovative service.